Families deserve more than an apology

Yesterday marked twelve months to the day since the State Government placed a full-page advertisement in The Advocate Newspaper, and others, notifying the public of the names of 177 deceased Tasmanians. They did so because the deaths had been investigated by autopsy, and parts of their remains had been unlawfully and secretly retained and displayed in a museum at the University of Tasmania for decades.

This extraordinary step was taken because the families of the deceased had never been informed. The remains were kept and displayed without their knowledge or consent.

Most of those individuals died in traumatic circumstances between 1966 and 1991. Many of their families had spent decades living with the emotional scars of sudden, violent, or unexplained loss. To learn—via a newspaper advertisement—that the remains of their loved ones had been treated in this way forced those families, against their will, to relive their trauma. Sleepless nights, renewed grief, anger, and distress followed. It is a textbook example of how not to act in a trauma-informed way.

In a small state like Tasmania, news travels quickly. Families who did not see the advertisement themselves were told by friends or relatives, compounding the shock. After the initial wave of anger and pain, questions remained: how could this have happened; who knew; how did it go on for so long; and why did it take decades for families to be told?

Some families, guided by religious or deeply held personal beliefs, sought to have a say in how their loved ones’ remains would be handled. Their views were inexplicably ignored.

The Coroner’s record of investigation, published in September last year, answered some questions. For many families, however, it raised even more. They turned first to the Government for clarity and explanation. When answers were not forthcoming, they came to Members of Parliament like me seeking help.

In December, the Health Minister delivered a Ministerial Statement apologising for what occurred, acknowledging the harm caused, and indicating that a formal apology would be made this year. That is welcome, but it is not enough.

These families need proper support and counselling. They need full and honest answers. And they need accountability. Anything less will be seen, rightly, as an empty gesture.