TasNetworks’ failed negotiations causing suffering: Charlie speaks out against NW transmission development.

On January 15, Charlie* received a package in the mail. It was a ‘Notice to Treat’ letter from TasNetworks, in line with the Tasmanian Land Acquisition Act 1993 (LAA).

Before Christmas – landowners set to be affected by the proposed North West Transmission Development (NWTD) project from Palmerston to Burnie, received letters from TasNetworks with a final threat to reach agreement by January 14 before the process to compulsorily acquire easements would begin.

Charlie wasn’t expecting the final demand to occur the day after.

Charlie was willing to remain open to a fair negotiation but made the decision that they will not be signing a Licence and Easement Option Agreement (LEOA), as a matter of principle, after receiving an earlier letter of demand on December 9 from TasNetworks.

Charlie had no further conversations with TasNetworks or their representatives between those two letters.

No-one reached out. No-one checked in. Just another letter of demand, but this time, the stakes were higher.

When Charlie spoke to their second land agent in November, the agent had just come back with a price offer.

Charlie explained that they weren’t happy with that, and wanted a fairer compensation, in line with public reports that were coming in from other property owners and farmers expected to host the new towers and lines. Charlie just could not fathom why there were such extreme differences between what was being offered. There were no more offers.

Charlie, along with other landowners who refused to sign up to a deal, were threatened with the loss of the Strategic Benefit Payment, if they didn’t sign up by December 1.

Ironically, it was these threats that compounded the reasons that motivated Charlie to continue to refuse to sign.

Charlie also believes the land agent assigned to them, flat out lied when questioned about the compensation differences being offered. They said this occurred when discussing other properties and transmission alignments, with the agent suggesting the lines were going to go over the top of one farmer’s house, and that was the reason for the difference in compensation offered, but in fact, the lines were at least 150m away from the house.

That agent has since resigned, and Charlie hasn’t talked to an agent since.

In conversations with the original agent in the early stages, Charlie often shared points of agreement with the agent, but it was clear the agent was there with an agenda, to sell the product, with the constant claim that Marinus and the NWTD would put downward pressure on power prices and the transmission projects would be a great thing for Tasmania.

Charlie had some meaningful discussion, but when it came to the crunch, it was clear that both agents were only repeating the talking points they’d been given, with little to no interest in meaningful negotiation.

With claims by some landowners that signing up to TasNetworks’ offers was like ‘winning tattslotto’, Charlie detailed they weren’t feeling the same when they received their offer. Charlie also empathised with other owners in his situation, recognising the impact on landowners with smaller parcels, who were being offered lower compensation packages even though the net impact was proportionately greater because of the percentage of the property being affected.

Charlie’s view was that TasNetworks didn’t give them time to go through system they advised, before then sending out the Notice to Treat letter on 14 January.

Charlie saw the last stages of the ‘negotiation’ process as being rushed and poorly timed, by sending a notice at Christmas time – only giving landowners a month to get things resolved during what is generally a shutdown period for many offices in Tasmania.

TasNetworks did not wait to allow Charlie to get a new valuation, who had been waiting for the strategic benefits payment figure to be finalised. Even though it took two years for TasNetworks to come back to the negotiating table with Tas Farmers, & finalise the Strategic Benefit Payment (SBP), TasNetworks only gave individual farmers a few short weeks to make a final decision.

By the end of January, Charlie still hadn’t been able to resolve the dilemma created by TasNetworks and their unrealistic timeframes for negotiation.

Charlie detailed that they and other landowners have been putting up with TasNetworks representatives for 5 years. Given the mental toll and stress that has been placed on landowners, Charlie assumed that others have probably had enough too, or perhaps even succumbed to the pressure.

According to Charlie, the whole process was shambolic and unfair.

At the end of the multi-year process, the decision by TasNetworks to cut the negotiations short and send an ultimatum to landowners, allowing only 30 days to barter an agreement to sell their easement, or risk the easement being acquired under the LAA. Charlie did hope that an opportunity for fair negotiation would come, but has been deeply disappointed by TasNetworks, and it may now be a matter that ends up in court.

The moral challenge for Charlie during this saga is that it wasn’t just about the property impacts, but what has been and continues to be at stake for the wider community.

*Charlie is a pseudonym that has been used for the affected landowner.